[Edit] I think it was actually baryons which are composites of an odd number of fermions if my memory of college physics is right
So that could be a dense cloud, or a very, very large but diffuse cloud of gas or dust, and there are a couple of galaxies that rotate too quickly for the number of stars we can see, and don't have enough visible dust to explain why they don't fly apart.
We're talking about needing to find something like 20 times as much stuff in order for the universe to make sense with the physics we have. And while I expect finding more stuff will improve the signal-to-noise ratio, at some point we should be looking for new physics, because new physics is where we find ways to do things the old physics says are impossible.
Edit: I meant "yes, someone with more knowledge please answer this question". Not "yes, it could be dark matter"
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massive_compact_halo_object
(that doesn't mean it's categorically wrong, just decided to be so unlikely to be correct that it's not worth our time)