France, UE, Covid, democracry and the research of complete stupidity
blog.luap.info
blog.luap.info
Not that his points are all invalid. But as usual it is a gross exaggeration of a complex reality. Plus, we tend to forget what is working and the progress we are making. Sure France is definitely not a country to "move fast and break things" but it doesn't mean you can't start a successful business, or change the society little by little.
The internet is full of unfocused ill-informed rants; I don't see what's HN-worthy about this one.
Here's a specialist, explaining it (in French) https://youtu.be/CgQ3YBmiir4?t=660
CDC: https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/downloads/2019-nco...
WHO: https://www.who.int/news-room/commentaries/detail/modes-of-t...
Harvard Medical School: https://www.health.harvard.edu/diseases-and-conditions/preve...
BC CDC: http://www.bccdc.ca/health-info/diseases-conditions/covid-19...
UC Davis: https://health.ucdavis.edu/coronavirus/covid-19-transmission...
There are plenty more; I think it's clear that "pretty much" every epidemiologist agrees masks are important, even if it's not absolutely everyone.
Raoult just want to be on TV to satisfy is ego and sell books.
- People get fired every day in France. The set of valid justifications and processes are explicit.
- EU legal harmonization is a work in progress that respect sovereignty.
The last part probably deserves medical attention :
- vote / don't vote
- Educate / don't listen
- Climate change will kill / Live a pleasant life
France has its specific problems, but other countries have other problems. Poland technically has lower taxes and a more welcoming environment for entrepreneurs, but much lower human and financial capital to build on, something the author dismisses about France, but should compare to other places first.
I think it also highlights that to make progress for oneself and for the world is always hard, uphill, thankless, and when you make it, you mostly get abuse for it. I think, accept it, or go back to Kindergarten.
“we are all going to die of climate change, that is good because it will be easier to rebuild. At least it is worse in the US.”
I liked reading this perspective though, really interesting from an American perspective because some political parties often hold up France as an ideal country in many regards.
California is moving in the direction of France in regards to the government being the necessary parent of ‘stupid’ citizens who want to work in non-ideal conditions. I understand where they are coming from, but there are so many obvious unintended consequences that are worse... I wish the U.S. had smart politicians as well.
"France is in terrible shape. We've voted in a system that has an enormous regulatory environment that stifles business and kills small and medium size endeavors, which move to the US if they are to succeed.
But it could be worse, we could be the US."
Okay. Sure. That makes sense.
Seems pretty self defeating to me. But I guess that's what you mean, for better or worse.
Populism isn't only talking to simple minded people, it's taking the language of your audience and offering simple minded solutions that seem to make sense.
That's how you get on the path of deep-state or QAnon conspiracies or countries with cults of personality veering on authoritarianism (Russia, Turkey, USA...).