What do you think is unconvincing about them and in what way do you believe that expertise in Photoshop has any relation to this technology?

At best Photoshop can play a role in covering tracks of evidence or artifacts of this much more sophisticated approach to faking identifies.

It’s not to say the developers and scientists at Adobe are lesser, it’s that it’s not the same tool or problem that’s being solved.

Put crudely Photoshop can let you draw a mustache on someone’s photo. This is about inventing a photo that never existed before.