Ask HN: Small Desktop Recommendations? | Hacker News Reader

Ask HN: Small Desktop Recommendations?

2 pointsrman6666 comments

Hi. I'm looking for recommendations for a small desktop.

I'm normally a Mac guy, but I need a system to develop relatively simple desktop applications in .NET using MS Visual Studio. It seems I'll get the most for my money if I buy a small desktop and access it across my network using Remote Desktop from my MacBook.

Obviously, I'd like to get as much CPU, RAM, and SSD as possible. I'd also like it to be quiet (i.e., no fan?) and be available immediately (i.e., 2 day shipping).

I'm a n00b when it comes to using Visual Studio, so I'm wondering: Are there any flaws in my thinking, AND do you have any recommendations for a small Win 10 Pro desktop under $1K?

View on HN

https://fanlesstech.com reviews lots of completely silent computers generally using standard components. I would go with something with standardized components if you can as the case, the power, the heatsink etc may all be reusable.

https://simplynuc.com will equip you with a NUC mounted in a fanless case. This means a proprietary motherboard/soldered chip and a case no other computer can be mounted in, which left me with a rather expensive and useless case when an older NUC died. A NUC is a very small line of computers made by Intel, they're basically laptop hardware repurposed as desktops.

https://quietpc.com has lots of fanless and near-silent machines too up to full workstation-size desktops but the smallest ones all tend to be the Intel NUCs.

I currently have a 6-core/12-thread NUC with a 1tb NVMe which is even smaller than a Mac Mini. But I hesitate to recommend this as it has a 10th generation processor saddled with the years-old Intel HD620 graphics like the Mac Mini, my 2013 MBP with Intel Iris outperforms it. It requires an eGPU for anything even slightly graphically intensive.

https://liliputing.com/2020/04/intel-frost-canyon-nuc-10-rev...

Very useful. Thank you.

Define "small desktop". SFF-sized? Smaller? Price, size, and capability are tradeoffs.

For whatever it's worth, I'll vouch for the HP Elitedesk Mini series and the Dell Optiplex Micro series. If the current generation units are too expensive, previous generation units can be found cheaply on eBay and maxed out with add-on parts.

Yes, I'm thinking SFF. The HP Elitedesk Minis are beyond my price range (new) but I will check the Optiplex Micro series and prices on eBay, Craigslist, etc. Thank you.

What about this one:

ThinkCentre M715q Tiny

Actually, that's pretty much perfect! Thanks for the reply.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com