Hacker News Reader

Comment by ljcus10 | Hacker News Reader

Does anybody believe Apple is making money off this? Redirecting websites to competitors.

Probably not tbh - the cost/benefit of getting such small amounts of money versus enormous reputational damage is not remotely worth it.

My question is can they bid on it behind the scenes like a keyword. Siri suggestions must have some type of revenue.

It would be a poorly considered algorithm rather than some bidding situation. No sane person would build this intentionally. The big companies have too much to lose especially.

Basically, this is Google's entire business: getting paid to send us where someone else wants us to go. Google are "big". Why wouldn't Apple want in on this action?

Sponsored search results are marked as such in the Google results, it's nothing like the automagic redirect Safari is showing here.

Apple uses this to promote first party services like Apple Music, Apple News, and App Store. All of these generate revenue for Apple.

If they land on Google, then Google would be promoting YouTube Music, Google News, etc, which is lost revenue for Apple.

If it was an autocomplete thing all sorts of words entered would be generating false hits.

These are super specific high value search terms. Apple is most definitely being paid to do this.

Guccc -> Gucci.com Gucce -> Gucci.com Pradd -> Prada.com Praada -> Prada.com

Low value target words just seem to go directly to google searches though.

It's just a bug. We could use bug reports of this because it doesn't seem to reproduce for everyone.

Wouldn't it be google doing it if it is set as the web search engine?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com