I doubt it. Anyone with the slightest knowledge about Seibel knows that he is super competent. What Reddit will judge him on will be what they perceive as hypocritical policy making; loss of subreddit and user power; and the lack of transparency.
I think most of the world doesn't have the slightest knowledge of him, though. This is really sad because everyone I see on here who does know him is saying great things about him.
I think people are interpreting this comment as suggesting what this HN user will judge Seibel on. I don't think that's what arkitaip is conveying. I believe they are just stating the parameters that Reddit has often judged high-profile executives or board members on, e.g., Ellen Pao. The keyword here is "perceive."