My recollection, assuming it's the same machine I'm thinking of, is that it wasn't reserved for our team; rather, we left a do-nothing job permanently allocated to it, in order to prevent some poor other sucker from getting their job scheduled on it. (Because we, through painful experience, were well aware the machine had hardware problems; but we had long since given up on convincing the responsible parties to take it out of the pool, since it passed all their internal tests every time we complained. I don't remember how long this situation existed before someone finally took it out back and shot it.)

Could be a different incident and a different machine, though. I'm sure this story happened more than once.