Hacker News Reader

Comment by haecceity | Hacker News Reader

Interesting to see how people deal with this information given that mainstream media has instilled in us that the moral responsibility of the disease lies in China.

View on HN

> moral responsibility of the disease lies in China

Is there a another opinion on this? It's where the virus originated (Lab created or from eating a bat or even US military doing it - whatever you are opting to believe) in November 2019 and it took them until late Jan 2020 to say that there's human to human transmission despite their own doctors warning and telling the world earlier than that (and they were silenced)

That is patently false. The CDC head was briefed by the Chinese "around New Year's Day" 2020 (https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/28/us/testing-coronavirus-pa...). By Jan 7, 2020 the CDC had already setup a task force to deal with the COVID threat. I certainly don't want to defend the Chinese government. I'm sure there are a lot of things they did wrong (on top of all the horrendous human rights abuses they commit on a daily basis), but the whole narrative of blaming China for COVID seems like an obvious ploy to shit blame away from our own incompetent response. The fact of the matter is that we saw this coming in slow motion and comprehensively failed to respond in a way that could have prevented this human tragedy.

Even if they knew, if they had themselves been moral and decided to stop all travel, it would've been fair to say we are all responsible. They did not do that. Sure all the countries are at fault too definitely (me, as an Indian, included) but doesnt take away the fact that Chinese authorities downplayed this and led to the spread. No matter how you put it and the moment it had spread world over, stopped flights to China to stop spread.

Sorry, all governments are to blame here, for sure (these deaths cant be justified) but China and to a large extent WHO are in the blame here too. Majorly.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com