Hacker News Reader

Comment by statictype | Hacker News Reader

The best way to get feedback from users would be for Apple to provide, as part of the iOS API, a widget that lets you do the rating right there in the app itself.

When prompted 'Would you like to rate this app?', if you choose 'Yes', show a ratings widget and comment box right there in the dialog without booting you to the App Store.

View on HN

The ratings are probably more meaningful for requiring that users go out of their way to rate. Make it too routine and the courtesy fours drown out the users with strong opinions.

Edit for the downvoters: this is me speculating on how the ratings work in practice. Whether the system is fair or serves your own interests are both seperate issues.

I disagree. There have been several times when the 'Rate this app' modal box came up and I wanted to give a good rating for it but couldn't be bothered because it sent me out to the AppStore when what I really wanted to be doing was playing that game/using that app.

Look at it from Apple's perspective. They want at least some great apps to float to the top and terrible apps to be tarred and feathered, while bothering users as little as possible. They don't particularly care about giving every app an accurate rating or capturing every user's opinion. Thus, they don't have much reason to push users to rate more apps.

You should check out my startup http://www.crittercism.com Its like Uservoice but for mobile apps. If a user submits a bug and you fix it the library lets you prompt affected users to leave a good review.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com