Does MIT ask for AMC/AIME scores which are miles above the SAT Math Subject tests?
Frankly, in order to stand out among MIT applicants by demonstrating some sort of mathematical ability on these exams, the minimum is probably USAMO qualification (top 270 of ~200k AMC takers). Otherwise it's a nice thing to have but not particularly unique. Even then I know a reasonable number of USAMO qualifiers who have been rejected.
Source: was a MIT undergrad < 5 years ago