Hacker News Reader

It's not a modern problem. You could always rig a tamper-proof device (eg booby trap) to destroy evidence if forced without the key.

View on HN

While true, this is also a much more modern problem than the authors of the US constitution were subject to.

If you stab people, you can wipe the blood off the knife. If you shoot someone, there was not a way to associate a projectile with a firearm. (Assuming the dubious merits of "firearm forensics".) Back in the good ol' 1780s, there's no presecutorial evidence to be gained by inspecting my safe because you cannot show that the knife/gun inside was the murder weapon.

That’s quite a different problem, because if the booby trap goes off, the person who set it can’t be compelled to un-destroy the evidence.

Not entirely if you account for secure elements which might erase the secretif the wrong pin was entered too many times or if an wipe code was entered.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com