Hacker News Reader

Comment by mister_hn | Hacker News Reader

True, but we forget how also Chrome attempts to set itself automatically as standard browser in Linux _WITHOUT_ asking. That is also a malicious behavior, isn't?

View on HN

Why are you trying to change the conversation to Chrome?

Can't speak for OP, but tu quoque arguements are common!

Because the "don't be evil" in this case doesn't apply, speaking of browsers

And unproductive. We should judge each company by each own demerits, not excuse Microsoft's behaviour with Google's and vice versa!

It doesn't sound like mister_hn is excusing Microsoft's behaviour. It's just that, if people think Google is the "victim" here, they are completely wrong. They both have little regard for a user's preference.

People think the end users are the victim here. This equally applies if my default search engine is something else. Bing is still going to override it.

Hear here!

Not trying to change the conversation, but also Chrome has malicious behavior without consent.

IMHO, browsers from Big Corps shouldn't be trusted at all. If someone likes to use Chrome, should try to go for Chromium or a de-Googled version of it.

About Microsoft, don't use Office then, move to something else, the world has plenty of alternatives (LibreOffice or SoftOffice are really good ones)

For what it is worth, it seems like even Microsoft can’t make Chromium work without phoning “home” to Google. The new edge preview (at least for me, not sure if A/B testing) still talks back to the mothership at 1e100...

How hard can it possibly be? ungoogled-chromium is a thing and they seem to have gotten it right.

Why does anyone on this site ever talk about anything but Firefox. We should all know better, and put our full collective force behind Firefox.

The market leader sets the terms. Behaving maliciously didn't hurt Chrome - consumers obviously don't care. So you fight fire with fire. Otherwise you're at a disadvantage.

Spare me the whataboutism to justify Microsoft's actions.

If Chrome did that it would be objectionable too.

Exactly. Imagine if Google changed your windows installation to point shortcut to win word to point to a new chrome window in kiosk mode that opens docs.new...

Chrome literally did something like this. When the user searched the web from the Windows search box, it used to open their default browser to bing.com. Chrome started to inspect the url and redirect to Google.com. So Microsoft changed it to open Edge to block this bs.

I would argue the inverse. I set my preference in Chrome. Why is Windows forcing me to use Bing if I use the search box in Windows 10?

Like making Google search the default?

It doesn't sound like he is trying to justify it. He's suggesting that the popular alternative is just as bad. In no way does that make Microsoft's action any better.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com