For now, that's all I can say...
Just to be clear, our decision to not use Scout wasn't because their service was bad. To the contrary, the service itself was very good. It just required a little bit too much setup and required a high degree of inference from the sysadmin. You more or less had to read the code in some of the plugins in order to make things work. That added up to more effort than I felt we were getting in benefit when compared to something like a local Munin install.
The monitoring product idea was created because of that exact issue. Nothing seemed to really solve the problem for us. I'll definitely refer back to this comment often.
You can follow me directly on twitter (same username) for any feedback or suggestions.