The Political History of Pad Thai
scmp.com
scmp.com
It's no wonder that Pad Thai and other Thai cuisine is ubiquitous in many countries, with the Thai government putting so much effort into 'gastrodiplomacy' [0][1]. I'm certainly not complaining!
[0] https://web.archive.org/web/20130926085448/http://thailand.p...
[1] https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/paxadz/the-surprising-rea...
I went to Thailand a couple of a years ago and visited a restaurant in Bangkok that was supposed to have the best pad thai in the country. It was decent, but I've had better in the UK. The best thing about the restaurant was that every table had a pot of peanut dust that you could add as liberally as you liked to your meal.
Tastes differ on which variations are best, but I agree with the ground peanuts (and lime and pepper powder and ideally served with cucumber slices...)
Italian seems more bimodal, you have cheap pizza joints and sandwich/sub/hero shops and you have the white tablecloth places. Japanese is either $$ or $$$ (in rest pricing parlance). But rarely do you get cheap Japanese or cheap Korean though Korean rarely goes to $$$. (maybe LA has super fancy ones) Indian mirrors Korean. I think they kind of loosely mirror the economics of the population that brings the cuisine and those that give it their patronage.
At least where I'm from there's bimodalism in Japanese cuisine if you count sushi rolls, which can be had dirt cheap (pretty localised/internationalised though). I like cheap sushi here because the cheap sushi game is usually locked down by koreans, so the rolls end up being this blend of kimbap and sushi rolls.
Dunno about Korean restaurants in the west though, have only been to Korean restaurants in Korea.
edit: Wish I was from/lived some place with nice cheap Italian sandwich shops etc, that must be amazing.
To edit further, I think western consumers' perception of a country (as well as what you said about the country's population) affects price as well
Scale used: $ (<10€), $$ (10-17€), $$$ (18-45€), (>45€).
In Australia it is similar. Roughly speaking, the following cuisines have these types of price ranges:
Indian: $-$$ Chinese: $-$$$ Thai: $$ Japanese: $$-$$$ Italian: $-$$$$ French: $$$-$$$$ Local: $$-$$$$
It seems that Asian is fairly set on low-mid, while European can go higher and still do well. Same with Japense and Chinese. Italian has been so integrated into the local cuisine that you have very cheap to very fancy. French is rare so more expensive. Japense also rare, though sushi train type places are becoming more popular (though still on the pricer side).
Chinese: $-$$ Tex/Mex: $-$$ Indian: $-$$$ Thai: $$ Japanese: $$-$$$ Italian: $-$$$$ French: $$-$$$$
Note: Tex/Mex, Italian, and Japanese availability, quality, and pricing vary widely according to where in the country you are.
I'd chalk up French to the 1980s. As in "If you wanted to be a really good chef, you studied French cooking", which resulted in popular "If you wanted to go to a really fancy restaurant, it was French."
Thankfully, that seems to be fading in the urban US in favor of more local/fusion emphasis.
Not enough fancy Thai places though, only 1 really unique one in all of the Seattle area to the best of my knowledge.
1. Dong Ting Chun is really good.
2. Liuyishou Hotpot.
3. Núodle has some good dishes.
Cheap places are "Australian Italian", usually with incredibly generic menus and large servings of bland food. That's your Lygon Street Italian, if you're familiar with Melbourne.
Expensive places usually serve "Italian Italian".
For contrast, here's Universal's menu, which is a "Lygon Street" Italian restaurant: https://www.universalrestaurant.com.au/menu
Compared to nearby Tipo 00, what I would probably consider to be more authentic Italian (although still not 'expensive'): https://www.tipo00.com.au/food/
There are also significantly better inauthentic-Italian experiences around, like Capitano which takes its cues from Italian-American food culture.
Logic being a couple sushi rolls for lunch type thing is about as cheap as it gets and these places are everywhere.
https://qz.com/747757/your-newfound-love-of-korean-food-is-a...
Interestingly, it turns out that competent governments are able to export culture and brand in a directed, purposeful way (as opposed to organic) if they put enough money and effort behind the effort and have the right kind of staffing.
It's fascinating because most government tourism boards rarely achieve success. I'd never have imagined that bureaucrats would know anything about promoting the arts.
How do you figure that? Most government tourism advertising is branding, and not specific to a business (it's usually "Visit X" with some motivational photos, where X is a country or region). Countries certainly have brands, are perceived in a certain way. Are you suggesting that brand advertising has no effect on this? Is it that brand advertising works for brands other than countries?
To really create interest in a country, one has to export a desirable mainstream cultural product like food or media. One has to tell a story, and good branding requires a compelling story.
I mean, if all there was were nice advertising of sandy beaches and temples in Thailand, etc. I'd probably not be motivated to visit. Nothing wrong with it, but there's no emotional connection because there's no narrative (sandy beaches are everywhere, and there are temples in most Asian countries -- there's nothing distinct about these things in themselves). But the tourism board of many countries stick to this formula because there's not much imagination on what else there is to be done.
On the other hand I've eaten Thai food regularly due to the ubiquity of Thai restaurants in North America, watched viral tearjerker Thai commercials on Youtube, watched Muay Thai (popularized by American movies like Kickboxer, and more recently by Tony Jaa's movies like Ong Bak), read stories about Bangkok's traffic jams where people have to pee in a cup (probably hyperbole), seen Thailand featured on travel shows like Bourdain's -- the result of which I now have a human connection to Thailand and made me want to visit. (I did a few years ago and really enjoyed it)
I can't say I have the same feelings about Indonesia for instance, even though it's the 4th largest country in the world and probably quite fascinating to visit. Australians frequent Bali because it's a nearby tropical destination, but I'd bet many people around the world couldn't tell you much about Indonesia if you asked them. Now imagine if Indonesia started exporting its food, which I can attest is quite good based on what I had in Amsterdam. That would start a whole new conversation about Indonesia.
I'm no advertising expert, but I don't believe that brand advertising doesn't work. It's clear that Thailand is already more salient and relevant to you, but that doesn't mean that advertising for Indonesia is pointless; it's just that it's starting with fewer hooks, and it's got to reach for stories more indirectly.
Take Canada for instance -- I'm from there. Anthony Bourdain had this to say on Canadian tourism ads: “Whoever is in charge of promoting Canada abroad completely have their heads up their asses. It’s all like bears and swatting salmon and Mounties.”
Canada is so much richer than the stereotypes Americans have of us -- we're not just about the pristine wilderness, cold winters and funny accents. Canada's cities are culturally deep and have a dynamism fueled by immigration that is palpable--and more compelling than many U.S. cities--due to sheer Brownian motion collisions of different cultures. The dynamism of Toronto rivals and in some ways exceed that of Chicago where I now live.
So much culture and innovation is being created every day in food (especially in Montreal), TV shows, movies, universities, arts, etc. in Canada but no one has figured out how to sell that.
To be fair, there are some small successes: Anne of Green Gables for instance is a distinct cultural product that guarantees hordes of visitors to Prince Edward Island every summer without fail and with a near zero advertising budget. We need more of this.
I read a while back that Leonardo's movie The Beach kick started the Thai tourism.
I don't agree with this. There are many examples of Tourism boards successfully selling a country really well. 100% Pure New Zealand, Incredible India, etc
This was very much the tenor of the times: Hungary had achieved dual status in the "Austro-Hungarian" empire half a century before; by the 30s "national" self determination was all the rage thanks to WW1, Woodrow Wilson, and picking apart the bones of the Ottoman Empire.
I am not a member of any of the groups involved with no axe to grind (at least in this regard!). But since the article was both a fun trivia piece but brushed against this topic I thought it worth clarifying.
The Indianness of the tea wouldn't have been a relevant thing if it's being made in India for other Indians after all. So why would Thai people invent a style of boxing and then call it "Thai style boxing" even in their native language?
It hadn't occurred to me that it was all a top-down effort to create a "national identity" and didn't organically develop from the folk culture at all.
There’s a chai/Tea plaiting the world’s languages. I have a parent from each side.
It has nothing to do with its country of origin (I assume you meant China?).
The northern dialects' word sounded more like "tea" which is where the Western languages got their word for tea, through trade
> The root of the word “Chai” is in fact the country of its origin —- which is not india.
which seems to imply that cha somehow is related to the name of the plant's country of origin.
The reason is really to tell that kind of coffee apart from e.g. Italian or French coffee styles (we call filter coffee "French" whereas we don't call anything in particular "Italian coffee" but of course there's lots of preparation styles that originate in Italy).
So sometimes maybe it's a bit of a mix? If you have a variety of something that's distinctly different from what your neighbours are using you might want to call it "my-style X" just to know what you're talking about. Of course then there's a bit of nationalistic pride that comes with it "this is how _we_ do it" etc.
________________
Like it makes sense to me that we might have domestic boxing and then decide that boxing from the country across the border is [Neighboring Country] Boxing. What was confusing for me is people calling THEIR OWN style of boxing "[Our Country] Boxing."
FWIW, in the case of Muay Thai it was basically invented as a sport in the modern age. It's derived from an older martial art known as "Muay Boran," which translates to "Ancient Boxing" and is more analogous to traditional martial arts like Kung Fu. Muay Thai was developed to create a Thai national sport to compete with Western boxers.
Pad Thai is top down designed. Made by the government to be appreciated by most people, but with enough character to make it distinctive of the country.
Ramen is bottom up. That's essentially people trying to make survival food taste good.
And it shows. The base recipe for Pad Thai is always the same, just like with traditional food. Individual chefs then add their own personal touch.
Ramen however vary wildly. It is a soup, and there are noodles in it but beside that there is no real recipe. There are some common themes (ex: pork, onion, seaweed, ...), but you will probably find more exception than there are rules.
While a restaurant can claim it serves "true" Pad Thai, "true" Ramen makes no sense.
> The lungs, heart, and liver of a sheep boiled, ground, seasoned, mixed with oatmeal and stuffed in its own rectum to be boiled
I will never.
> with salsa and cheese and served with sour cream and guacamole.
Oh, doesn't sound so bad. I'll give it a shot.
Hey we're no monsters. It's the heart, lungs & liver of a sheep stuffed into it's _stomach_ not it's rectum. (Though often these days it's in an artificial casing, the whole stomach thing seems to put people off).
I like the hypothesis, though I wish this was tested. In my experience, rice can be pretty airy once it's been scooped.
Nevertheless, pad thai is amazing.
Going to dinner with lactose intolerant folks, vegans, veggies, and carnivores? Thai will easily serve everyone, and there will be multiple choices for each person.
I suspect it has something to do with the large amount of Thai women immigrating here...hell, even in my small rural hometown of 3000, there's one Thai restaurant, and one Thai food truck. Every neighboring town and village has the same.
And you always see them selling spring rolls etc. on facebook buy / sell groups.
Pad as in iPad?
Or closer to pod?
The vowel in "pad" is in between the two options given in the question above. Unlike English, where accents primarily change the vowels, vowels stay quite constant across accents in Thai.
[edit] oh missed the “she” so you’re right. Probably?
https://www.scmp.com/lifestyle/food-drink/article/3007657/hi...
I'm sorry but what on Earth are you talking about? I can only assume you have simply never visited Thailand? This is just so inaccurate I don't know what to say.
In tourist hotspots (which abound in Thailand) you'll tend to see picture menus and Pad Thai will be on them. But there are much, much better dishes to be had outside these areas. One issue is they don't all have consistent names, e.g. when I asked for a recommendation and was given an absolutely amazing dry curry crab noodle dish with egg, I asked for its name in Thai and translated it was "curry crab" which would never get you a similar dish in another restaurant. Even the venerable Pad Kee Mao, which I think is always a noodle dish in America, is sometimes a totally different rice dish in Thailand.
I used to work at the HSBC tower on Sathorn, in the heart of Bangkok's financial district. There was a simple open-air shack just outside that served (IMHO) the best pad Thai I've ever had at 25 baht a plate, and the place was packed every day with everybody from suited bankers and lawyers to tuk-tuk drivers. I don't think I ever saw another farang on there though.
Also, proper pad Thai is not spicy, like all noodle dishes in Thailand it's supposed to be served with condiments (chili flakes, phrik kii nuu in fish sauce, sugar, ground peanuts) so you can tweak the flavors to your liking.