Hacker News Reader

Works great! I've never been a fan of the game Set myself, but enjoy seeing these projects that bring classic games online. I remember enjoying an online version of Puerto Rico, many years ago, that was something like a Java Applet app. Wish that still existed.

Side note, "With Friends" is a trademark owned by Zynga; I have no idea if they aggressively go after even personal projects, but just an FYI in case you didn't know.

View on HN

Probably more important, "SET" is a registered trademark, and the game is copyrighted.

See here for a previous demand:

http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~treuille/resc/set/

Can you copyright the game mechanics? I don’t see how eg words with friends could have ever existed if so.

You can't copyright a game mechanic, but you can copyright content. This is why Words With Friends has a different board layout, tile distribution, and tile point values from Scrabble.

In that Set C&D, the infringing implementation is using art assets from the copyrighted Set game. Presumably, a version with different colors/shapes/etc (and a different name, so as to also avoid trademark infringement) would be totally fine.

This one? http://www.compoundeye.net/jsanjuan/

Nope but that one looks great. The one I played is http://www.phial.com/puerto-rico/ (which apparently still exists). Apparently, it's a Curl web applet.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com