The Yellow Fleet (2018) | Hacker News Reader

The Yellow Fleet (2018)

amusingplanet.com

23 pointsallovernow10 comments

What a crap fluff piece. The wikipedia is much more informative. Like explaining why it took 8 years to open Suez https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yellow_Fleet

99Percent Invisible's episode about the Great Bitter Lake Association might be a better resource.

https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/great-bitter-lake-ass...

> The crews were rotated every three to four months. Over this eight year period, some 3,000 men did duty on the stranded Suez ships.

Why did the ships need to continue to be fully manned?

According to the documentary I watched there was hope that th canal would open and they were kept ready to sail home. But the cargo was written off as a total loss early on, and pillagaed/traded by the remaining crews.

> The Arabs and the Jews have never got along.

Already the first sentence put me off. Jews and Arabs have, in fact, gotten along very well for the majority of the past millennium. That last century has been the exception.

It's also ignorantly false. Never is a very long time. They were the same peoples or coexisted peacefully for the majority of known history. Only "recently" has there been divisiveness.

what about the whole slaves in egypt bit?

Aside from the fact that ancient Egyptians were not Arabs, mainstream history and archaeology no longer consider the Exodus described in the Bible to be a real historical event.

Here's one article about this, from the Israeli newspaper Haaretz:

https://www.haaretz.com/archaeology/.premium.MAGAZINE-for-yo...

> [The Exodus] never happened. For decades now, most researchers have agreed that there is no evidence to suggest that the Exodus narrative reflects a specific historical event. Rather, it is an origin myth for the Jewish people that has been constructed, redacted, written and rewritten over centuries to include multiple layers of traditions, experiences and memories from a host of different sources and periods.

Those weren't Arabs.

You get the same type of nonsense in regards to east asia. Like china, japan and korea have never gotten along and had been in an eternal state of war when in actuality, they had gotten along for most of the past millennium with the 20th century being an exception.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com