Hacker News Reader

Comment by circlefavshape | Hacker News Reader

Wait

> I had a freight elevator door pin my hand and damage a bunch of nerves while I was helping someone move furniture into his illegal Brooklyn loft. I got $50k for it.

You were doing something illegal, got injured, and sued? And you say "the system is broken"? The system is broken because of behaviour like yours

View on HN

Much of Brooklyn's "residential" offerings aren't legally residential. They're old commercial buildings that landlords have cheaply repurposed to get a piece of the rising demand in housing.

I lived in Bushwick for a year and a half, never met my landlord, and I'm sure the building was breaking at least a dozen laws, but it was relatively affordable so no one really asked questions.

"Illegal" apartments in converted warehouses are very common in Brooklyn. Supposedly, the city turns a blind eye to them. Once someone lives there, they can't be evicted, even if it's not a legal residence. So renovation works happen without a work permit.

At least, that's what my brother told me, who lived in such an apartment. It was an eccentric place, but everything seemed up-to-code.

Yes. That's why they told the anecdote.

Being in the elevator wasn’t the illegal part though.

Nor was moving stuff in it.

Only the occupation of a non-residential space residentially was.

The system is still broken, regardless of what you think of GP's actions. "You shouldn't steal our customers' passwords" isn't a clever response to being told that your customers' passwords have been stolen and sold for $50K.

The apartment was illegal, possibly not zoned for residential or not up to code. The act of helping someone move would not be illegal. He had every right to sue.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com