Hacker News Reader

Comment by onion2k | Hacker News Reader

Probably a silly question, but why can't you charge the iPad in flight? Surely planes have some sort of socket like cars?

View on HN

The point was to compare battery life and care for equipment. I cannot mod the plane to add a 12V socket, but I can use an external battery pack. Still, 5 hours vs several days comparison still makes the smart watch good enough.

>Surely planes have some sort of socket like cars?

Unfortunately no, and often it’s not trivial to legally install one.

If you can install an iPad surely it wouldn't be too difficult to also install a battery pack to boost the battery life if nothing else.

That's fair, but you'll still need to keep the battery pack charged :)

Can you put a little solar panel instead? :D

Pretty sure you can, but you’ll have to use tape and not screws to hold it in place so it won’t be a permanent installation :)

But yeah, go experimental and then you never have to worry about these things. Lots of great value kit planes out there.

The issue is certified aircraft. I think the 'certified' USB charger was around $300 for the part when we installed one - in addition to the certified mechanics time. The experimental side is cheap.

The Tecnam P2008 has a 12v socket and it's a rare luxury in an otherwise awful plane. Most single engine piston aircraft don't have charging ports or 12v sockets.

I had one in my '67 182 and two in each of the 58P and then A36 that replaced it. I seem to recall them being present even in the Piper rental airplanes as well.

Or a nice 20-30mAh portable battery? Those charge my iPad Pro like 5x.

I think you meant Ah instead of mAh, or 20000 mAh instead of 20.

Curious why you think planes surely have outlets in them?

We're not talking about jetliners here. We could easily be talking about planes that are suitable for clear conditions only.

My light plane has six 2.1A USB ports for charging use plus several others dedicated to avionics updates that can also charge. In addition I have three 24V cigarette lighter "outlets" which have two dual port USB adapters. So... Plenty of on board charging foe the six seats. Not hard to retrofit. I only wish I had more!

What's the plane and did it come with these or did you or someone else add them?

It's trivial to have such things for your plane (talking about small planes with propellers etc used for hobby flying, commercial aviation of course would have specific requirements) -- it's getting them to pass the relevant regulations that's the deal. Eg.

https://www.aircraftspruce.com/menus/ps/ipad_usb.html

That sound less like a plane and more like a flying USB hub. :)

I know very little about planes and think of them as being very like cars, and a 12v socket is a cheap and useful feature in practically every car since the 1950s (more recently USB has replaced them) so I assumed planes might have the same thing.

I would expect them because I would have expected that back in the '50s and '60s people would have started using their plane's cigarette lighter socket for powering things, just like they did with cars, and so people got used to having power available and thus manufacturers would keep including it even when cigarette lighters were no longer standard equipment.

And yes, small planes used to have cigarette lighters.

There's an airworthiness directive from 1979 that required owners of a bunch of Cessna models to either disable the cigarette lighter or add a circuit protection device. There's a copy of that AD here [1]. It includes a big list of Cessna models and serial number ranges, which can give a good idea of how common cigarette lighters were.

[1] http://www.cessna172club.com/forum/ubbthreads.php?ubb=showfl...

My C182 had a 24v cigarette lighter plug that was there when the plane came to me and I think was from the factory. Took a while to find a 24V USB charging dongle, but when I did it powered my iPad just fine.

Well, I've been to small Chessnas that did have...

Reply on news.ycombinator.com