Hacker News Reader

Thank you.

I never knew about help to describe a builtin shell command. normally searching for something like "command" in the bash man page would be very tedious.

also: help echo

View on HN

How little we expect from our computers. "help <command>" should be the first thing you expect to work.

i do think 'man command' should bring up the specific man page for this, so there is no need to search into the bash man. this works with most builtin shell commands. e.g. 'man ls' is a thing

On (at least) Debian systems (, and probably many more) `ls` is not a built-in, but an external binary (`/usr/bin/ls`) is used.

`which ls` and `help ls` will show you, if it is similar on your system.

It does't need to be a built-in to have a man page (many first party and third party libraries come with their own man pages).

"man command" on linux says "no manual entry for command"

"man echo" on linux describes /usr/bin/echo "help echo" describes the builtin.

on the othe hand, "man command" on mac os x gives a huge manpage of builtins (still hard to search for the common word "command")

Reply on news.ycombinator.com