Hacker News Reader

> You think giving birth is free?

This is a straw man argument. Nobody is suggesting public healthcare is without cost. Civilised societies provide services like policing, fire and rescue, criminal legal defence, and education, because these are deemed rights. The United States is an outlier in not regarding healthcare a right to be supplied as a public service.

View on HN

It's as much of a strawman argument as the Twitter image is, then, since the image is literally a picture of a hospital bill.

One argument doesn't mention the subtext of socialized medicine, and the other doesn't mention the subtext of insurance.

You can support public spending and yet not necessarily think of it as a "right". For example, I support tax-payer funded education because it's a bargain; an educated citizenry is much more productive.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com