Comment by blackhaz | Hacker News Reader

Comment by blackhaz | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

Holy freaking cow - please no to this, and no to the thread below about "old annoying UI." Thunderbird is a workhorse. I process over 15,000 mails per quarter - manually. I write a lot, I read a lot, and Thunderbird is my home sweet home every day since the time I've left The Bat! at version 3 something. (The Bat is awesome as well but exists only for Windows...)

Thunderbird is the best e-mail client out there. It doesn't need a new UI, colors, animations, apps or any other bells and whistles. It looks great on Mac and BSD. Please, people, don't vote for it to be yet another Apple Mail or another "Web 2.0" or whatever is now considered cool or hip. I don't need that shit. I need a stable standard client that can handle Gigabytes of e-mail without corrupting files. I can rsync my own shit to back it up. I love being able to dig into custom settings manually. I can manage stuff myself. There are others people like me. Just don't get into my way and turn my computer into your computer.

Sorry, this has to be said. Thunderbird is awesome. Cheers, peace and love.

I wholeheartedly agree - Thunderbird is awesome, one of my favorite programs out of the ones I use daily, and has worked well for me for over a decade. I know of no alternative that is suitable for me.

While there is a bit of room for improvement, I dread the types of changes to Thunderbird that are so often discussed. Now that a generation has been raised on webmail, it seems that very few even understand the many benefits of Thunderbird or why someone would not want webmail.

I'm not the right person to try to teach people about the benefits of Thunderbird or educate them on why webmail is a scourge. Thank you for your comment - at least it will help people start to realize that there might be a silent majority out there like us that find great utility in Thunderbird and that aren't looking for a Gmail clone or a copy of the Apple equivalent.

-------

Edit: fixed typo.

Well, Thunderbird has been taken over by people who aim at 2 goals:

* replace internals with more Web tech (I say more, because Thunderbird unfortunately already used some);

* 'modernize' the interface.

So you can abandon all hopes and regret the time it was supposedly unmaintained.

Will there be forks? I remember Phoenix forked from Firefox. 0.99 was awesome, then Phoenix became Firefox after they overloaded the browser with crap.

Phoenix forked from Netscape Navigator 6. The renaming to Firebird and then Firefox were entirely about trademark conflicts.

I wholeheartedly agree with you. I'm not using another email client because I don't want a dumbed down version. I simply want a less buggy and faster feeling Thunderbird. Just some polish here and there.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com