Personal feelings are not how we evaluate a scientific discipline. It's phrenology level nonsense.

A coworker once told me that his chiropractor told him he could help him with hemroids. This not only made me dubious about her ability to cure hemroids. It made me dubious that she could do anything about back pain. Capable people don't spew nonsense within the scope of their capabilities.

The second his analyst registered an opinion about the personality of the writer I became dubious that she could even tell who wrote it.