I recently redeemed my Amtrak points for a free ticket and then needed to change the ticket which required a phone call. The gentleman on the phone asked me for my “points PIN” that was apparently required to change any Amtrak points reservations. I had never needed to change any points reservations before so I didn’t have one.

Amtrak’s solution? I could set a PIN, right then and there, verbally with the agent over the phone. No logging into my account. No email or text message confirmation. They didn’t even ask to confirm my DoB or address. Nothing. I had only given him my reservation number.

And not 30 seconds after creating my new PIN the same agent was then able to “verify” my identity/account by asking me... for my PIN.