Comment by beatgammit | Hacker News Reader

Comment by beatgammit | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

If we are to add a law here, I think it may make sense to require contracts to be easy to understand and as short as is reasonable. I think it's pretty reasonable for someone to skim over fine print especially for something that seems obvious.

Something like a safe deposit box should be a single page document with something like this:

- cost is $X/month and prices are revaluated every Y months and can increase by a maximum of $Z/month - may access the box X times/month without any additional fees - bank's liability is max $X or Y months of rent, whichever is higher/lower - if rent is not paid, X happens, and after Y months of non-payment, Z happens - policy/fee for lost keys

I haven't actually opened one, but I wouldn't be surprised if the contract was 10 pages long and the maximum liability was somewhere in the middle in fairly small print.

I like the way Creative Commons licenses do it. First there is a simple bullet-point-wise summary for layman like this: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/ . Then there is the entire legal code for lawyers: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/legalcode .

I think all contracts should be written like this. If any clause of the legal code contradicts the summary for layman, then the summary for layman should take precedence during its interpretation in the court.

This practice is not unusual. Books often start with a preface or foreword. Very dense technical or research papers start with an abstract and introduction. But for some reason contracts do not follow this practice.

If the summary takes precedence, then what purpose does the legal code serve?

The details.

How would that help with this - "Banks typically argue — and courts have in many cases agreed — that customers are bound by the bank’s most-current terms, even if they leased their box years or even decades earlier."

We could also take the mortgage approach, where the actual contract is in fact very long, but there is a required simple-to-understand cover sheet that summarizes all the pertinent details in a clear way.

Quick google - Chase’s contract below, bold print middle of the first page.

https://www.chase.com/content/dam/chase-ux/documents/persona...

Interesting clause. There’s no insurance and no guarantee of protection against anything. One wonders what stops them from keeping your stuff in a basket next to the mints.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com