Hacker News Reader

Comment by the_watcher | Hacker News Reader

Neat! Anyone working on projects to improve the share-ability, code review, version control, or web rendering of Jupyter notebooks, feel free to reach out to me when looking for an enthusiastic early user. Jupyter has been a game changer for my productivity as a data scientist, but I still struggle with something that seems as simple as "what's the best way to expose this to other people easily without having to set up a self-hosted nbviewer".

View on HN

Two projects I've been watching with interest are https://kyso.io/for-teams and http://reviewnb.com.

ReviewNB is very promising! I just wish it could live within Github (my idea is something like how Zenhub reorganizes issues into a Kanban board - add a tab that only allows viewing of ipynb files), since right now I have to kind of cajole people to review notebooks on their site.

I am the developer behind ReviewNB.

> I just wish it could live within Github

Whenever I thought of integrating the review experience in the GitHub UI (via browser extension), I always thought of overwriting the GitHub diff UI. That approach is very hacky and would result in the extension stability issues (any DOM change in GitHub diff could break the extension).

But I just looked at Zenhub and having a separate tab for notebook review could actually work! Since it relies only on the tab related HTML, the extension would be relatively stable. There's still a question of how to post comments etc. But it might be a good start to just offer notebook diff in a separate GitHub tab for pull requests.

Thanks @the_watcher.

Glad you saw this!

We are developing a Notebook like interface for SQL https://uktechdata.count.co/ https://stackoverflow.count.co/

Welcome to get your thoughts on this.

Is it tough to manually convert the md and use a CMS like Ghost or Hugo for website?

Alternatively, exporting HTML and publishing can also help right?

I'm curious why did you say so. Moreover did you check the recently released `voila` package that lets you publish Jupyter notebooks?

There are a bunch of ways that make it _possible_ to do all of this. What's really missing is a way to make it as easy as committing code to Github repo without having to do anything more than install a Github extension.

Right now, I do my work in a notebook, it's automatically converted to a Markdown file (for code review), and I use nbconvert to generate static html, which gets deployed to an internal docs site. I've also been tinkering with ReviewNB, which is trying to make notebook review look like code review, but it's separate from Github and is still fairly unpolished (but very promising!).

Ideally, the experience could be something like: * Install Github extension that offers a notebook review tab and automatically converts notebooks to a static HTML file that can be served from a url directly accessible from Github

I can think of a bunch of challenges involved in doing something like the above, but my experience working somewhere that offered a tool that allowed me to literally click one button within my notebook and have a shareable url that contained my notebook and the ability to comment line-by-line taught me that this massively unblocks data scientists, who will otherwise end up copy/pasting stuff into documents just to deliver things to partners faster.

> and is still fairly unpolished (but very promising!).

I'm all ears. Please write to me at amit@reviewnb.com

I built ReviewNB and push improvements almost every single day :)

By the way, voila looks very promising as well, thanks for the pointer.

https://github.com/mwouts/jupytext looks like something you might enjoy. I'm not affiliated with the project in any way.

If you send me an email (dan@kaggle.com) I'd love to set up a time to show you some mockups that may be the solution you are looking for.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com