Random cheap things I've had stolen:
- old spice deoderant 6 pack
- listerine
- pepto bismol
- ibuprofen
- $20 azamax plant pesticide desperately needed while a houseplant was being destroyed by fungus gnats. Enough value I suppose but so random to steal.
- aquaphor (the tubes of stuff for dry lips)
- a box of pencils
I could honestly go on for much longer if I went through my purchase history. I live in a nice neighborhood in Boston and have a locked lobby where they drop off packages that I guess people tailgate into with high success. Or I suppose ringing the bell to a random apartment and saying "UPS" probably gets you buzzed in on most days.