Hacker News Reader

What if your DHCP doesn't give you a private IP address? When I was at the University of Michigan, my personal laptop always received a public IP address. Or if I'm in a pure-IPv6 setup, using prefix delegation/SLAAC? This problem is a lot harder than "just use the RFC1918 list of reserved private IP ranges".

View on HN

Fixing the issue for people on properly configured networks is already an improvement worth doing.

The UMich network isn't "improperly configured". NAT-less networks have been around since the beginning of the Internet, and IPv6 networks don't use NAT (unless they're accessing IPv4-only targets, but that's CGNAT). I think you'll find a great deal of university/research settings have networks configured without NAT. If you can come up with a solution that works in all cases, I'd love to hear it.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com