Hacker News Reader

Comment by akuji1993 | Hacker News Reader

akuji1993

There is a massive drop in nodes at https://the-federation.info/pixelfed. Seems like a SPOF host deactivated their 50 something nodes?

Other than that I'm skeptical about this. If it doesn't host ads or any other money making scheme, how do you pay for servers to host some many pictures? Being image focused, I imagine the server gets expansive fast when your node becomes big. This might also explain the SPOF deactivating their node.

View on HN

Seems like the drop is everywhere according to that website. https://the-federation.info/mastodon

I would say either the chart is wrong, the data is still being collected or something is very wrong with the federation system.

The chart on the main page is already bouncing back.

Typically some fediverse hosts asks their users to support them on crowdfunding platforms while others are run by small groups and not accepting new members.

Okay, that might work for smaller groups. I guess my head is too much focused on hyper-scaling, which might actually not be the goal here... Other than scaling / hardware space, I think the idea is great btw. My first post sounded very negative, I actually like the idea a lot.

Think the idea is to have lots of small communities which can communicate with one another. If this ever takes off, I am sure that for-profit instances will eventually be founded as well and they may/may not contain ads as part of their business model.

I think you are correct now; a number of fediverse projects actively seek to avoid getting big. For example pixelfed creator has closed signups on his instance and mastodon encourages people to sign up for different instances (and I a number of existing mastodon instances has also closed signups because they are big enough, and everyone except banned users and instances can just federate anyways.)

That's the point of federation, so you don't have to worry about scaling any one particular host. As long as the network can scale, the community and product can grow. That will depend onhaving efficient clients and servers, and a well-designed protocol.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com