Hacker News Reader

Comment by _nalply | Hacker News Reader

If you don't give your kids smart phones you cut them off of people. It's a conundrum.

You will only be able to keep your kids off smart phones if you live in a community not using smart phones much for example the Amish. I think parents of the one percent could also create such a community for their children if they are diligent and choose the right private school.

My 6 year old son will go to a summer camp where smart phones are expressly forbidden. Not that I give him a smart phone but at least the older children won't have smart phones, too.

View on HN

Yeah, I suspect it really requires a community of like-minded parents.

Camp is a good start. For what it's worth, one state in Australia just announced a ban on phones during school hours - couldn't agree more.

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2019-06-25/victoria-to-ban-mobil...

That's not enough, I am afraid.

I think we should think holistically, this means, don't only look at school but also at family, peer relations and society at large.

In other words I propose that we should completely forbid functional smart phones for children below 10 years then officially introduce smart phones in school as a part of the school's curriculum. The curriculum also limits usage and relaxes the rules when the children get older. Children also should have a say about rules.

Also needed are places where children and teenagers can meet and these places must be autonomously accessible (for example near the school but independent from school).

Such a community allows the children to learn about internet and social media in a safe and controlled manner. I think the children would prefer to play together instead of staying alone in bedrooms anyway.

How on earth could that ever be realistically enforced?

The Amish know how to enforce their own rules.

By common values and mutual consent. What you're proposing, in the context of broader society, would have to be imposed top-down. Maybe I misunderstood and you're just saying it as a nice what-if, in which case I would agree that small children should be grounded in the physical world first.

Yes, this is a what-if, and for some lucky people even achievable (Amish and one percent).

> If you don't give your kids smart phones you cut them off of people. It's a conundrum.

You cut them off from people if they don't have a $1000 computer in their pocket?

Dumb phones are still a thing. They can call, text, and many have a camera that can send lower-res images. I think that's way more than enough to stay in touch. They don't need "Apps".

Sorry to tell you this, but teenagers don’t text anymore. They use apps instead - Instagram, Snapchat, Whatsapp, Telegram - because texting is a broken system that doesn’t work reliably. If you cut your kid off from a smartphone, given today’s teenagers, you would be excluding them from anything social outside of school.

> because texting is a broken system that doesn’t work reliably

Oh really? Could you elaborate on that? I, as a high-tech professional in my early 30s, keep in touch with my pals in a group text. It's never failed.

Does your friend group include both iPhones and Androids? From experience, any group chat that includes both is going to result in splits (like in IRC), messages simply not going through, and messages arriving multiple days late. In addition, they don’t have the usability features that you get from apps, like read receipts, or being able to add a person to a group message and them being able to see the entire history.

EDIT: That said, you don’t need a $1000 iPhone. A $200 used smartphone (easily found for iPhone or Android) is good enough.

Point well taken. Apps do provide some usability boost and it's true that in a mixed iOS/Android setting things can get funky sometimes, but I always assumed that it was a carrier issue.

As much as I hate Facebook, Messenger is pretty damn solid.

You cut them off from nothing. I'm a 34 old data scientist without a smartphone, and I'm not cut from anything, why would they?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com