Hacker News Reader

Hacker News

Comment by chasil | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

chasil

Why do you find it odd? I find it to be the very best introduction to C-style control structures.

Chapter 2 of The AWK Programming Language has incredible benefits for a novice.

https://archive.org/download/pdfy-MgN0H1joIoDVoIC7/The_AWK_P...

View on HN

They probably refer to how it has the top-level as

  <line-condition> { <code> }

That's unusual enough among programming languages to call it odd. Being able to do stuff like

  if (/some-pattern/) { ...

and have the regex be evaluated like a condition where it matches with the current line implicitly is also pretty unique.

  if (/some-pattern/) { ...

This isn't really unique when you consider perl.

  while (<>) {
    if (/pattern/) {

This does the same. Awk simply has the implicit loop.

Yes, I think Perl based that on Awk, but then those are the only 2 languages I know that support something like that. That's still very unique. On the implicit loop, along with Ruby, they're the only 3 languages I know that support something like that. That's also pretty unique, and Awk is the only one that has the implicit loop as a requirement.

The implicit loop is uncommon among general-purpose langauges, but very common among filtering-centric languages like awk and grep and sed. For a more recent example, see jq. perl 5 may be close to the only mainstream general-purpose language to have embraced that paradigm though.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com