Comment by DonHopkins | Hacker News Reader

Comment by DonHopkins | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

I still think the PowerBook 540c was the best Apple laptop that I ever used.

Although I had switched over to Windows by the time of the Pismo G3/500 (voted the best ever), I had my 540c upgraded with a PowerPC, and got many years of delightful service out of it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PowerBook_500_series

I had a 5300 for a while and it was a piece of crap compared to the sturdy souped-up 540c.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PowerBook_5300

It had two big symmetrical removable battery compartments, so you could switch out one at a time and keep running on as many batteries as you have pre-charged without interruption! Plus there was an external dual battery charger.

And you could swap a hard disk drive or CDROM into one of those bays.

Plus it was fat enough that it was able to cool so it didn't overheat all the time like an MBP.

Anorexic thinness isn't a thing for me: I'd trade a lot of thinness for huge removable batteries and great ventilation.

https://web.archive.org/web/20060324140419/http://www.insane...

I never really liked the 500 series - I preferred the 1400 (I know, weirdo). The Intel MacBooks have had their moments (glass trackpads, SD card readers, quad core in the 2011 15"), but almost all of them had design defects of some kind:

* Original white and black MacBooks had sharp edges and cracking wrist rests

* 2nd Gen MBP had 8600GT chip death issues

* First Unibody MB/MBP had glossy screen not suitable for indoor lighting

* First Polycarbonate Unibody had chassis cracking and rubber base warping issues (but was otherwise an excellent machine, too bad they didn't resolve those issues and keep selling it...)

* 2011 15" will all eventually fail due to faulty GPUs

* 2012 Retina MBs had underpowered GPUs

* Retina MBPs had soldered RAM and proprietary SSDs (10.13's NVMe support for those older machines with a simple adaptor has made a complete mockery of anyone defending Apple's stupid proprietary pinout, too), glued batteries and display coating problems

In saying that, the original aluminium unibody was a spectacular design. It felt so much more premium than any other machine of the time it was absurd.

I personally think absolute peak Apple notebook was the 2012 MacBook Pro 15" with the Anti-Glare display. All the best things about the pre-retina Unibody design, but serviceable, with USB3, no known serious GPU or CPU flaws, and none of the retina issues such as staingate or glued battery.

Had they made a Haswell revision of that to get the better battery life I'm reasonably convinced it would still be a seriously popular machine today.

>* First Unibody MB/MBP had glossy screen not suitable for indoor lighting

This didn't affect me (and it didn't change until Retina, I think), but EM209 <https://randyzwitch.com/broken-macbook-pro-hinge-fixed-free/... hit me twice, the second time not covered by Apple.

Oh the glued hinge right behind the hot air vent is hilarious. I forgot about that one.

Yes, glossy screen had an anti-reflection coating added for Retina models that then proceeded into staingate. To make matters worse they took away the matte anti-glare option entirely because they thought their new compromise was best. Yelp.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com