Reddit Commenter's Fight for Anonynmity Is a Win for Free Speech and Fair Use

Two big wins:

1) The First Amendment protects the audience as well as the speaker.

2) The court carefully reviewed the fair use factors and concluded that "they tip sharply in Darkpilver’s favor."

And a pretty big loss:

The counsel for the Jehovah's Witnesses get the identity of the Reddit user anyway, even though the copyright claim is "far-fetched".