Foxconn Still Trying to Tap Dance Around Its Ever-Shrinking Wisconsin Promises
techdirt.com
techdirt.com
https://gimletmedia.com/shows/reply-all/wbhjwd/132-negative-...
It's a good listen even now, now that this story has played out the way it has..
Wisconsin got played really badly, but I don't understand what even Foxconn is getting out of it at this point. Did they just change their mind and decide it wasn't worth building a factory there at all, but for whatever reason just won't come out and cancel it all?
[1] https://www.pennlive.com/nation-world/2017/03/how_foxconns_b...
[2] https://www.zdnet.com/article/foxconn-set-to-discontinue-bra...
In the end it was not worth it for Foxcon. And I think a terrible outcome for Brazil. Electronics are absurdly expensive there (Think import tax 1, import tax 2, import tax 3 and in the end taxes on the import taxes. No kidding).
Stuff is often three times the price of western prices. At least in the past. It was common for people to ask you to sell them you used Laptop/iPhone/mp3 player.
"However, the promises soon proved hard to keep: the company wanted the Brazilian government to come up with 30 percent of the cash, as well as a private investor - both failed to materialize. "
"As well as the economic instability that the Brazilian economy, it is also rumored that other factors influencing the decision include the productivity of the local workforce - which at its peak reached about 2,500 workers - which Foxconn considers to be low when compared to its main manufacturing operations. "
https://www.google.com/search?ei=eBbgXMeXFeOW_Qba2pWYAg&q=sc...
https://www.jsonline.com/story/news/politics/2018/07/31/scot...
> But the most plausible explanation I heard is that Foxconn’s secret is that it has no idea what it’s doing in Wisconsin.
> “In China, people announce projects like this all the time, and some of them get built, and some of them don’t,” said Willy Shih, a Harvard business school professor who consulted in the screen industry for several years. They’re called “state visit projects,” he said. Politicians get a photo op, and companies to get some political goodwill, but everyone knows the announcement is extremely preliminary. Ultimately, the company will do whatever makes economic sense, and sometimes, that turns out to be nothing.
> Foxconn has done this in the past, announcing large factories in Pennsylvania, Brazil, and elsewhere that never materialize. But unlike Pennsylvania, which offered Foxconn no incentives and built no infrastructure, Wisconsin politicians threw a tremendous amount of money at the company and rushed to acquire land and start building.
> Further complicating matters, the trade war with China still looms, and Trump has personally called Foxconn CEO Terry Gou when the company wavers. This time, Foxconn can’t simply vanish without risking a backlash, but it also makes no sense for it to build what it initially promised.
tl;dr Foxconn made a bunch of empty promises in Wisconsin to curry goodwill with a US administration whose trade wars threaten Foxconn, probably expecting the hot air would be understood as such by the politicians, as they would be in China. Wisconsin, under Walker, grossly overcomitted to Foxconn’s silly promises, and now both the State and Foxconn are trapped in a deal that makes no real sense for either party.
Minor correction: Walker was governor of Wisconsin.
Apparently, Foxconn has been known to (all over the world) make a large promises in the name of getting tax breaks, etc and then only actually doing a fraction of what was promised.
[1] https://www.theverge.com/2019/4/10/18296793/foxconn-wisconsi...
In return Foxconn curried favor with President Trump, who tied himself to the factory coming, and the political party in control of both house of Congress at the time.
But those who advocate for more taxation, how do you stop this kind of corruption?