As a sex positive liberal, I admit a certain level of schadenfreude at seeing tumblr's decision bite them in the butt. Using child porn as a pretext to justify a puritanical purge of all erotic content is absolutely obnoxious IMO.
As a sex positive liberal, I admit a certain level of schadenfreude at seeing tumblr's decision bite them in the butt. Using child porn as a pretext to justify a puritanical purge of all erotic content is absolutely obnoxious IMO.
Classic comic from years ago
And not what Tumblr did - their erotic content ban was under way before the CP snafu got them temporarily kicked out of the iOS App Store. Consensus is that it saves them from SESTA-FOSTA legal troubles.
Plenty of porn subreddits around that could be used for sex trafficking particularly private ones.
https://www.reddit.com/r/redditads/comments/bdwlin/update_to...
Fewer, and lower discoverability. If you ban a sub, the mods have to bother registering a new one, and if you ban the mods too I believe they'll need to 'break in' new accounts to do that. Once they do, it'll just be an empty sub sitting there passively until they promote it on other subs (where it'll draw reports) or on other sites (which is a hassle). And without active moderation, spam users destroy spam subs by overwhelming their intentional content.
On tumblr, a new account just takes a new email, and they can be 'promoted' easily because following real users or reblogging their content with ads sends them notifications. It's pretty much the ideal structure for automation-friendly spam.
They got kicked off the app store in november, and moved to ban all porn in december. They might have been planning this all along, but I've seen no evidence for that.
Why was this legislation pushed through so quickly without any opposition like SOPA or PIPA?
I don't get the "why".
Who was behind this?
"New statistics shared by the San Francisco police show... sex trafficking shot up 170 percent in 2018." https://www.dailydot.com/irl/increase-sex-trafficking-sesta-... They claim it's just improved reporting because of increased outreach.
"DiAngelo says she received calls from women who are suicidal because they’ve been forced to work on the streets and return to dangerous pimps." https://www.kalw.org/post/one-year-federal-law-curb-sex-traf...
"Breyer estimated that there were about double or triple the usual number of workers seeking assistance." https://www.theverge.com/2018/5/1/17306486/sex-work-online-f...
"online private group chats where sex workers could share survival strategies and harm reduction techniques to stay safe have also disappeared" https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-features/anti-s... (Banner image kinda NSFW)
Here's an actual survey of sex workers in Seattle. https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1KBsVBQh7EsRexAyZacaf... (results start on slide 7)
And it's had effects internationally. https://www.news.com.au/lifestyle/relationships/sex/sex-work...
Oath apparently viewed the adult content as a nonstarter for monetization and a general threat to advertiser relationships. Since both the site's design and its massive engineering flaws meant adult content showed up anywhere, it was even driving advertisers away from not-necessarily-adult content like user feeds, and there was some concern it was even keeping user counts down.
Of course, the entire plan here was nuts. Oath apparently wanted to double user counts by summer 2019, even though growth was effectively zero and there was no plan to fix that. They confused an adult content problem with a spam problem, and so the spam is still going strong. And the monetization outlook is genuinely hilarious: Oath intended to ban adult content as a step to monetizing the site's fandom and social justice communities. Apparently nobody noticed that the fandom stuff was the porn they were banning, or that a solid 20% of all users were going to be affected.
https://www.vox.com/the-goods/2018/12/4/18126112/tumblr-porn...
No longer can you see a nipple on Tumblr (well, you can, but that seems like what they're going for in blocking content), but a few errant clicks can easily find you in hardcore Tumblr bestiality territory that's apparently survived unscathed.