What "consensus"? I've read the Wikipedia article on the incident and found no information of any consensus of this sort. The objects in question were visually tracked by multiple aircraft, and were detected by multiple radar systems.
https://www.metabunk.org/nyt-gimbal-video-of-u-s-navy-jet-en...
But there was also discussion on skeptics.com and skepticforum.com when it was news last year.
Also note that the organisation that released the videos is a known scammer who has been caught trying to monetize the UFO community many times.