I don't know which kind they hit. But based on what's on the left side of runway 31L, I suspect it was a runway remaining distance sign, those are all black, and around 5' tall, and vaguely resembles the passenger photo of something black embedded in the wing.
Edit: Comment #77 in this forum thread is interesting if a true account. https://www.airliners.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=1420137&...
The aircraft would have been way off center of the runway, with the left wing literally dragging the ground.
JFK runway 31L is 200 feet wide, an A321 has a wingspan of 112 feet. The wings are 12 feet from the ground at the fuselage, and maybe two feet higher than that at the wingtips. The photos[1] show heavy abrasion under the left wingtip, presumably it was dragging the ground.
Edit: Disregard this, AV Herald links provide more info.