Vladimir Komarov went on a space suicide mission to save his best friend, Yuri
twitter.com
twitter.com
2011: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2342677
2016: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11072718
mirror: https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1116939111368097792.html
I'm with the authors, I wouldn't trust a Soviet era transcript of a space mission, anymore I would of a show trial.
But, this occurred in the USSR, so I don't think we really know what happened with any high level of certainty.
How exactly does that debunk the entire thing?
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo_13_(film)#Technical_a...
It is true that the flight was in response to the increased number of US flights over the preceding year. But I wouldn't necessarily say the catastrophe was caused by the rushed schedule here (remember, this was the _very first_ manned flight of the Soyuz), nor would I say that anyone was "saving" anyone else, or that Komarov knowingly embarked on a death mission. To say so would imply mind-reading powers, and I don't know anyone who possesses them, least of all some American dudes who wrote the book to make a buck.
The Wikipedia article also says the Soviets stopped manned flights for a year and a half after this disaster. All three of the hypothetical flaws in the parachute system were preemptively addressed, the Soyuz was considerably re-designed to improve safety, and six additional unmanned flights were carried out to make sure shit like this never happens again.
To this day, only two of Soyuz capsules resulted in crew loss out of 142 launches, and Soyuz is considered the world's safest manned space platform, and also the only one that's operational at the moment.
To "embellish" a tragedy like this is extremely disrespectful and irresponsible. I lived in the Soviet union in 1986 and remember when Challenger blew up Russians reacted with shock and commiseration, not some bullshit "embellishment" that invents astronauts "cursing" as they plunge to their death.
The capsule doesn't even have radio during the stage of the descent, where it is claimed Komarov cursed everyone, especially if it's spinning, as Soyuz-1 was, and there was no recorder left after the hydrogen peroxide fire. From this I conclude that everything that's not supported by the Soviet archive documents is total made up bullshit.
I feel like that childish "orange man bad" quote comes up as a reaction to anything potentially perceived as negative as if nobody could ever make a valid a comment, observation, write a story, whatever.
"This is an insult that stupid people think makes them sound smarter than other stupid people," as I've heard before.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thought-terminating_clich%C3%A...