Hacker News Reader

Comment by criddell | Hacker News Reader

I thought these multi-region searches were against Craigslist's terms of service.

Craigslist is famously aggressive about scraping, too. While helping with some university research, I found that their anti-scraping defenses were really difficult to get around.

They've also been litigious about this in the past, so this project would undoubtedly get a cease-and-desist if it ever became a blip on their radar.

I'm guessing that's because of AirBnB and how they got their start by essentially stealing posts from Craigslist.

I thought Padmapper got their start that way, by essentially providing a better apartment hunt interface than CL had at the time.

And they got the banhammer, too.

Not too hard to see where the fulcrum of this "settlement" is: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/06/padmapper-and-3taps-se...

Which was a shame, because padmapper stuck it on a map and linked to Craigslist, instead of just taking the content. If Google Maps did it nobody would think twice.

CraigsList might make them think twice. I don't think they want to overly exhaust their own resources, what they have works for them.

> I found that their anti-scraping defenses were really difficult to get around

What sort of defenses are they using?

I was a contractor at a company where one of the divisions did Craiglist scraping as part of the business model and they had a closet full of laptops doing the scraping part of the job - thirdhand what I heard was separate PC's were necessary for the anti-scraping workaround they were using.

They had fantastic detection of headless Chrome and curl requests, a thorough IP blacklist, aggressive rate limiting, and possibly some JS stuff.

All scrapey automated stuff is. I doubt this will be alive next week, or tomorrow.

already appears broken.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com