Whitman Senior Assessment
blogs.whitman.edu
blogs.whitman.edu
I have mixed feelings about the process. We had very limited support and education about the tools we were expected to use. (At that time, my program taught nothing about source control, nothing about web services.) They pretty much just said, "Go build a cool app on top of Sharepoint" and let the four of us spin for a year.
I learned a fair bit, but I also learned that in the college team project atmosphere, folks are gonna get carried and you'll be graded on the total possible output of four people.
Would I have preferred it to a massive test at the end of the year? 100% yes. Trying to build something practical was a great experience. I learned a ton that wasn't covered in my classes. I just wish I had more support/mentorship/pair programming along the way.
I think this is basically in keeping with non-college group project environments, broadly speaking. It’s easier for managers in an employment environment to judge output in group scenarios because feedback is often less structured than assigning grades in an academic environment, but the end consumer (whether internal or external) of a work product evaluates that product based on its result, not individual contribution. Ultimately, that all-up judgment ends up being more impactful than evaluation of individual contribution.