Hacker News Reader

Of course, it's better, because we can link to specific commit by sha256 hash, which is way more secure.

You can do that with a direct link too: bash <(curl -s https://gitlab.com/grownetics/devops/raw/ef053050065c4928714...)

No, you can't. Nothing will check SHA256 of a malware downloaded in this way, so nothing will stop malware from owning your host. To check, just put "127.0.0.1 gitlab.com" into your /etc/hosts and try to serve your own file from your URL. Git will detect this, curl will not.

Yes, try it. Unless something has changed drastically curl still checks that certificates are valid.

It looks like you assume that SSL guarantees correctness of the file.

First, I had experience with substituted SSL certificates (by our government, at revolution), when errors were reported by Chrome only due to certificate pinning for Google services.

Second, site can be hacked and replaced directly at the site.

When your threat level is government agencies then, sure, you have issues. But git wouldn't solve anything, unless you have a way to verify the hash or signature.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com