Hacker News Reader

Comment by magduf | Hacker News Reader

What I'm wondering is if it'll tell you to speed because that's the only way to break the cycle of getting stuck at every red light.

View on HN

Going slower would accomplish the same goal, save fuel, increase safety, and probably lots of other things that will look nice in the marketing brochure for this feature.

Not necessarily. Going 5mph on a busy street is surely much more dangerous than going 5mph over the speed limit (remember, most other drivers are also probably going at least 5mph over).

I completely disagree. Please don't go 5 over in places with pedestrians and stoplights.

This behavior is completely routine in every American city today. You're tilting at windmills.

going slow definitely should not be dangerous. speeding is dangerous. there is slight difference between city and highway infractructure. almost everyone forget that "speed limit" is not "recommended speed".

lets not stigmatize innocent people, and pursue those, who actually are breaking the law

No, because you can't reasonably ticket people for going only 5mph over. There's a reason almost no cops bother doing so, and set their threshold at 9 or 10 over: car speedometers aren't that accurate, cars can easily vary their speed a few mph as they drive, radar is only so accurate, etc.

And yes, "speed limit" really is "recommended speed", because that's how people drive in the US today. You wishing it were different will not make it so.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com