Hacker News Reader

Comment by latch | Hacker News Reader

Google search with site:news.ycombinator.com (and optionally a time limit, which I wish wasn't limited to past hour/day/week/month/year) seems consistently superior to what Algolia provides.

Algolia is YC company, so I assume that's the main reason it's being used. But that it does such an awful job with such a simply structured site isn't compelling.

View on HN

Hey latch, I've been working on the Algolia-based HN search and would love to improve it to provide you with a better search experience.

Do you think about any specific improvements? Would you mind sharing with us some non-working queries? We can follow-up here and you can also open issues on https://github.com/algolia/hn-search

Well, if I do "activemq vs rabbitmq" I then switch to "comments", I get 2 results. The 2nd hit is reasonable: "ActiveMQ: Not ready for prime time"

Google gives many more results, and a few on the first page seem quite relevant. Most notably: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5531192

but also: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1657574

I have just retested and the problem I mentioned before doesn't exist anymore, It has happened around Christmas time, back then, the search returned not very relevant results, Now it shows at the 9th position what google shows at 1th (exactly the article I was searching back then, still as first match on google), but this is a minor difference of order of the first page so I have to say the search is working pretty as expected now. Sorry for not retesting it before making that comment and thanks for keeping the search good. :all right I didn't want to say it but there: russia hypersonic

I just googled "elixir property testing site:news.ycombinator.com" and the first hit was what I wanted.

But it's the 3rd result in Algolia, behind stories that are both older and with fewer votes.

Thanks for sharing, this is a good example where the first 2 hits on Algolia have a "better" textual relevancy (proximity between words is better, because of the "-based" word in the middle) but where the 3rd hit is most probably the one we want to see first because it has more than 100 points while the 2 others have 3.

Let me share that to the team and see whether we can try something.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com