Hacker News Reader

Comment by shanghaiaway | Hacker News Reader

This is whataboutism. The US is restricting the free market - regardless of what any other country does.

It's only restricting foreign investments from certain countries like China that don't play by the rules. It's like banning someone from your store because they steal stuff.

The "free market" isn't anarchy, it's essentially a bunch of bilateral trade agreements

Nonsense. The US is restricting trade. Frankly, I'd like to see WTO step in here.

WTO will have little to say on the matter in the same way that it had little to say on the restrictions on trade China has enforced for its domestic market for decades.

Well these guys downvoting you never heard of export regulations.

Few links for those who are downvoting this comment above:

https://www.theregister.co.uk/2015/04/10/us_intel_china_ban/

https://wccftech.com/us-government-bans-intel-nvidia-amd-chi...

https://www.wsj.com/articles/u-s-agencies-block-technology-e...

https://venturebeat.com/2018/11/23/u-s-lobbies-germany-italy...

https://www.engadget.com/2018/08/14/us-defense-huawei-zte-ba...

> It's only restricting foreign investments from certain countries like China that don't play by the rules.

The US generally (in cooperation with Europe) wrote the rules on post-WWII trade.

I think China absolutely does some shady stuff, pathologically lies about doing so, and flaunts international rules they dislike.

But let's not pretend the game wasn't tilted against them (and developing countries) from the start.

There's a reason Trump is having a hard time staffing State and the Pentagon: everyone professionally qualified to serve knows how the current international system serves American interests.

(Said as an American)

The US should do whatever the US thinks it benefits the United States. China from the perspective of the US has the ridiculous restrictions on what American businesses can do. It is the high noon for the US to do the same.

It's like people forgot about the huge controversy surrounding Google doing business in China. The reason so many people were against it is because China was forcing Google to censor its search results to avoid listing anything negative about the Chinese government. The Google images search results for Tiananmen Square in the US vs China are drastically different, and that's not by Google's choosing. That's a demand from the Chinese government.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com