Hacker News Reader

Comment by warent | Hacker News Reader

Firefox supports it. You're aware Firefox is OSS right?

Firefox went walled garden in v37.

That said, at least this css grid garden has a elegant fallback. Most CSS grid sites don't. Or worse, they fall back to 'mobile' sites.

"Walled garden" in what sense?

The walled garden I speak of is the implementation of add-ons cryptographically signed by Mozilla only. Unless you run one of the betas (w/bugs) you cannot use any add-on not approved by Mozilla. And lately they've even been removing/banning add-ons that aren't illegal but otherwise upset outside corporations (ie, the paywall bypasser that uses googlebot's http headers substituted in).

Is there a browser you would recommend, if we ignored their HTML/CSS rendering for a second, based on ethical considerations, so to speak? I like making things compatible when I don't need anything modern, and would be interested in hearing about any browsers you think are worth supporting.

I would be very interested in this as well. Especially as someone who makes silly browser extensions they never intend to publish.

Is there a way to enable unsigned extensions at all, say from about:config?

No. The removed that in the low 40s versions.

You can either use the developer build or compile Firefox yourself.

Extended Support Releases do still include the flag: https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/add-on-signing-in-firef...

Your definition of walled garden is pretty broad and includes all major browsers.

Well yeah, they basically said that in their original comment. Is it not possible for all major browsers to be walled gardens?

It's important not to lump together the proprietary browsers (where the limit you speak of can only be worked around if the proprietors allow) and free software browsers which respect your software freedom, like Firefox.

You could modify Firefox source code to let you run whatever add-on you wish. With Firefox whatever changes you want are limited only by your willingness to implement them (either by doing the work yourself or working with others to get those changes made).

You can even distribute the improved Firefox variant browser to others and help the community. Hacker News recently had a story about some hackers doing exactly this with a variant they call Librefox. Other examples of Firefox variants include IceCat and the Tor Browser.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com