Was Cython given a consideration for this project?
I see that you are involved with the Pythran project, so could you tell us the shortcomings of Cython? As I understand it, before Pythran didn't support Python 3, but seems like that has changed
I see that you are involved with the Pythran project, so could you tell us the shortcomings of Cython? As I understand it, before Pythran didn't support Python 3, but seems like that has changed
In order to achieve top performance, in the context of numerical simulations, you generally end up explicity writing the loops are implicit in high-level numpy (less abstraction).
Cython does not perform any high-level optimisation on the code, while Pythran does. For instance Pytrhan computes whether an array index may be negative or not, and generates wraparound only when needed. On the otherhand Cython requires a compiler directive to do so.
That being said, Cython can do plenty of stuff Pythran cannot: import native libraries, wrap classes, mixed Python/native mode etc. It has a much stronger codebase (more tested/validated) and a larger community.
Thanks to both of you for the reply