>> those claiming otherwise refuse to look at the math and instead want to go with how the deal makes them feel.

its more than a little immature to accuse this of those who disagree with you.

your model relies on the fact that this would all be additional tax revenue that wasn't collected earlier. While a lot of these jobs can be people who already work in NY and simply switch jobs. In addition, it neglects the cost to the govt of servicing this company and all its employees. It also neglects the negative externalities and consequences for current residents (only looking at it through a money lens which is a typical neoliberal fallacy).