Hacker News Reader

Comment by binaryapparatus | Hacker News Reader

I have been using ZFS for over two years, on any desktop that I control, as both root file system for FreeBSD setups and backup file system in many configurations. In almost all cases I don't have EEC ram and I don't need it really. Your comment is either outdated or wrong, ZFS is THE go-to filesystem on desktop for me.

Edit: oh and it works beautifully with single disk setups too.

View on HN

Does anyone have any pointers to a resource for single disk ZFS setups? Last time I looked, most search results were entry points into a persistent flame war.

> In almost all cases I don't have EEC ram and I don't need it really.

That's like saying you don't need health insurance because you haven't got ill.

ECC is nice to have but absolutely not a show stopper if you don't have it. Plenty of articles and discussions online, example: http://jrs-s.net/2015/02/03/will-zfs-and-non-ecc-ram-kill-yo...

Claim that you can only use ZFS with ECC memory to feel safe is false.

While it is indeed false that one needs ECC RAM to use ZFS, ECC by itself helps keep the data is memory safe.

I used to use non-ECC memory on my laptop when running Belenix, and I now use ECC memory on my servers at Hetzner where I run my own Illumos builds.

(I'm one of the maintainers of Belenix, an early opensolaris based distro that was the foundation of Solaris 11. I'm working on reviving it again)

Wait until you get a 1-bit flip in a spacemap record. Then you just won't be able to import your pool (insta-panic). And good luck with fining and fixing that flipped bit.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com