Hacker News Reader

Comment by izacus | Hacker News Reader

The part of the context that's missing is the fact that Aptoide is one of the main channels for distribution of cracked and pirated Android apps.

View on HN

It's also the primary source of common free apps that only publish on the app store for people that run android phones without google accounts.

It still boggles my mind that organizations like keybase and protonmail refuse to shove an APK on an S3 bucket somewhere, it makes me feel like they don't really understand their audiences that well...

Anyway, for closed source free apps, aptoide has my back.

I use Yalp, it's an open-source front for Google Play

F-Droid [1] might be another good option for Keybase and Protonmail. F-Droid offers APK download from their website but also an app which reminds you of updates or installs them automatically if you had an extra permission extension and enabled the feature.

[1]: https://f-droid.org

F-Droid is a bad option because they're super-slow with packaging and updates.

F-Droid is a good option because they put users before developers.

They don't have the expertise or the manpower to fix their build system. That means it's not really feasible to use it to distribute your apk, unless it can be months out of date without any problems (such as your users complaining constantly, or things breaking, or a known exploit remaining in the client because it's impossible to push out a fix).

You can host your own repository if you so wish and have users download the app from the standard F-Droid app, similar to the many PPAs available for Ubuntu.

You end up having complete control over your APK distribution and users can receive updates through F-Droid.

F-droid certainly isn't perfect, but it's the best Play Store alternative I've seen.

You can always do everything yourself, and given that you can add repositories and the app handles it transparently that's a great alternative. That's assuming, of course, that you do have the expertise to run one. That certainly isn't true for most app developers I know, and that's logical - it's not their field.

It's definitely the best alternative, but that doesn't make it a good alternative right now.

f-droid is a fork of aptoide. Just interesting information that isn't that common knowledge.

F-Droid the client started out as a fork of the aptoide app, yes. This was quite a while ago and I doubt there's any resemblance in code or appearance at this point in time.

F-Droid the ecosystem is far more than that though.

It might be, if they were on there, which they aren't, which is why I specifically mentioned them as things I get best from Aptoide. I use F-Droid where I can, but F-Droid is special purpose: It's for open source software.

And with that nobody knows what you're actually getting...

Considering how often we see news about malware being distributed on the Playstore, that comment is also true for it.

I used aptoide to download morpheusTV. I'll gladly share my data for a slick netflix style interface that allows me to pirate any media I want. Trade off works for me.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com