Comment by paulgrant999 | Hacker News Reader

Comment by paulgrant999 | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

yeah its different here in the US. :) Everything is more polarized/political. Everything.

> Just the odd individual going off on one on some Facebook post or other net forum from time to time.

I discuss theology on a fairly regular basis ;) and philosophy. ;) lets just say there's a fair amount of "ex-Christians" who are looking for something new to latch on. Same old shit (hate/misanthropy), just wrapped in new cloth.

> "no belief in god" as an equally valid box to tick as CofE

Just leave it blank. What to your mind, is the purpose of having an explicit box? I'm curious.

> Humanism, some sort of earth centred belief, or Buddhism thanks to its philosophy and lack of creator have all risen as religion has become increasingly irrelevant for most.

Eh. I know Buddhist philosophy well. Few people get it. My friend who is an atheist (in the truest sense) is a humanist. So am I. Thats why we're friends. :) But he respects my choice to follow a religion; same as I respect his choice, to follow none.

> lets just say there's a fair amount of "ex-Christians" who are looking for something new to latch on

OK, that makes some sense. I don't think many have "committed" to religion and church in the UK for a century or more, compared to the enthusiasm that appears to exist in the US. Even many of those who openly believed rarely actually went regularly.

One formerly quite religious friend who lost faith in his mid or late 40s seemed quite apathetic for a while after. From my perspective looking on that was more that he lost the community, and group activities that he once regularly attended. Perhaps joining a new group or replacing the missing sense family would appeal. Thankfully atheist evangelists and militancy aren't a thing here outside of Dawkins. :)

> What to your mind, is the purpose of having an explicit box? I'm curious.

Hospitals might want to dispose of me in an appropriate manner if the risky operation fails. Passport applications insist on it (I think. It's been 8 years or so since my last). The clerk filling in the screen doesn't get much choice if it's a mandatory field they can't skip. It's sometimes gathered to try and ensure a lack of discrimination across large organisations.

> But he respects my choice to follow a religion; same as I respect his choice, to follow none.

This seems to nail it. Religion, belief, spirituality and atheism has become a personal thing separate and unrelated to organised religions in the UK.

> OK, that makes some sense.

wink.

> One formerly quite religious friend who lost faith in his mid or late 40s seemed quite apathetic for a while after.

runs deeper than that. people who are religious, usually are religious because it made sense. but the corruption in organized religion in the west, is difficult to reconcile with the actual tenets of a faith. so when they abandon their church; they still have the same needs that drew them - but now their is no path forward for fulfillment. Religion (in the purest sense), does have a purpose.

> Thankfully atheist evangelists and militancy aren't a thing here outside of Dawkins. :)

Indeed, you are somewhat blessed in this respect. I've always preferred a good conversation.

> Passport applications insist on it (I think. It's been 8 years or so since my last)

that would seem to be the thing to rectify. Unless your legal system is based on religious code; mandatory religious disclosure would seem to be a bit "impolitic".

> This seems to nail it.

He's a good person. So am I. Good people, prefer the company, of good people. Thus, has it always been.

> Religion, belief, spirituality and atheism has become a personal thing separate and unrelated to organised religions in the UK.

You guys have had a rough time of it. Speaking from a historical/religious perspective.

I'm not surprised by Western Christians jettisoning their "faiths". But it would be nice if they didn't impute the Western failures, say on Eastern or Middle-Eastern Christianity (which are vastly different creatures).

It distorts the mind, to project local problems, on all of humanity. Each culture is different; each takes a different path.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com