A: Of course potatoes are healthy! They're natural!
B: If everything natural were healthy it'd be healthy to eat hemlock.
A: Potatoes aren't hemlock and it's really offensive you'd make that comparison.
A: Of course potatoes are healthy! They're natural!
B: If everything natural were healthy it'd be healthy to eat hemlock.
A: Potatoes aren't hemlock and it's really offensive you'd make that comparison.
I have the same opinion on fallacies, practically every single time somebody says "wait, you just used a fallacy" it's wrong, it doesn't matter or he himself just used five fallacies by pointing that out. It's an endless battle over magic words that have so much social weight behind them that using them should be forbidden in any serious debate. That's my personal, very unpopular opinion.
As far as logical fallacies go: I don't like the Internet style of just rattling off a bunch of logical fallacies to dismiss an argument, but I think it's fair to say "this argument is such-and-such a fallacy because of X, Y, and Z."
If we took your suggestions I don't know how anyone would have a substantive debate at all.